On the evening of April 14, 1865, President Abraham Lincoln attended Our American Cousp at Fordis Theatre in Washington, D.C. He was shot later that night, an event that shocked the nation and altered the course of American history. A key figure who was scheduled to join the president that evening but did not attend has become part of enduring speculation about what might have been.
The person who was 'suppose' to attend the play with President Lincoln was Major Henry Rathbone, who was originally invited but could not go, leading to his presence in the box later that night. This arrangement, or misarrangement, influenced the tragic events at the theatre and left a lasting mark on how the assassination is remembered.
| Theater and Date | Key Figure | Planned Attendance | Actual Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fordis Theatre, April 14, 1865 | President Abraham Lincoln | Attended play as scheduled | Assassinated during the performance |
| Fordis Theatre, April 14, 1865 | Major Henry Rathbone | Originally invited, could not attend | Present in the box, injured during attack |
| Fordis Theatre, April 14, 1865 | Clara Harris | Invited as Rathbone's guest | Present in the box, witnessed attack |
| Unfinished Government Department | Ulysses S. Grant | Invited but declined | Did not attend, avoided tragedy |
Original Plan for That Fateful Night
The plan to see Our American Cousin was part of a rare evening out for President Lincoln, who had been absorbed in wartime duties. Invitations to the theatre were extended to a small circle of friends and advisors. Major Rathbone and his fiancée Clara Harris were among those invited, with Rathbone expected to accompany the president and first lady.
Grant and his wife had also been asked to join the party but declined, freeing up a box seat. Lincoln accepted the invitation without the Grants, and Rathbone, despite a late invitation from the president, remained with the Lincolns. This shift in plans placed Rathbone in the presidential box at the moment John Wilkes Booth struck.
Invitations and Their Consequences
Who Was Supposed to Attend with Lincoln
Understanding the invitation list reveals how close the tragedy came to involving different people. Major Rathbone was originally meant to be present, and his absence at an earlier event nearly altered history before the night even began.
Guests Who Declined
The decision by Ulysses S. Grant and his wife to skip the performance removed them from the box entirely. Their absence created an opening that would be filled by Rathbone and Harris, whose lives were forever changed by that substitution.
Henry Rathbone and the Night of the Assassination
Major Henry Rathbone, a trusted military officer, accepted an invitation at the last minute and joined the Lincolns in the presidential box. His presence that night was pivotal, as he attempted to subdue Booth and was grievously wounded in the attack.
Rathbone survived the Civil War only to face a tragic personal end years later, a reminder of how closely fate was tied to the decisions about who would attend the play with President Lincoln.
Historical Impact of the Attendance Choices
The mix of accepted and declined invitations shaped not only who witnessed the assassination but also how the aftermath was experienced by those closest to the president. Small changes in social plans took on enormous historical weight in that crowded theatre.
The story of who was 'suppose' to attend the play with President Lincoln continues to fascinate historians and the public, highlighting the fragile boundary between ordinary decisions and extraordinary consequences.
Key Takeaways on Lincoln Theatre Invitations
- Major Henry Rathbone was originally meant to attend with President Lincoln but his role shifted at the last moment.
- Ulysses S. Grant and his wife were invited but declined, creating an opening in the presidential box.
- The final arrangement placed Rathbone and Clara Harris in the box with Lincoln and Mary Todd Lincoln.
- Small decisions about social plans had outsized historical consequences on April 14, 1865.
FAQ
Reader questions
Who was originally invited to attend the play with President Lincoln?
Major Henry Rathbone and his fiancée, Clara Harris, were among the guests invited to join President Lincoln and First Lady Mary Todd Lincoln at Fordis Theatre.
Why is there speculation about who was 'suppose' to attend the play with President Lincoln?
Because invitations changed at the last minute, including Ulysses S. Grant declining and Rathbone accepting late, it raises questions about alternate histories and different possible outcomes.
What would have happened if Ulysses S. Grant attended the play with President Lincoln?
Grant likely would have been targeted as well, and his presence might have altered Booth's plan, but it also could have led to different casualties and a shift in the national mourning that followed.
How does the mix of accepted and declined invitations affect the historical narrative of Lincoln's assassination?
The combination of invitations, acceptances, and declinations shows how chance and personal relationships intertwined with a pivotal moment, shaping memory and historical interpretation ever since.