Consumer Reports toilets 2018 evaluations reshaped how buyers compare performance, comfort, and long term value across thousands of models.
These detailed ratings focus on durability, flushing effectiveness, water efficiency, and ease of cleaning, giving shoppers a reliable reference when choosing a new toilet.
| Brand | Model | Flush Performance | Water Efficiency (gpf) | Overall Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kohler | Wellworth | Strong, consistent removal | 1.28 | Very Good |
| Toto | Drake II | Powerful tornado flush | 1.28 | Excellent |
| American Standard | H2Option Keel | Dual flush option, solid performance | 1.28 / 0.9 | Very Good |
| Mansfield | Pressure Lite | Forceful pressure assisted flush | 1.28 | Good |
| Home Depot | Hampton Bay | Standard gravity flush | 1.28 | Fair |
Evaluating Comfort Height and Bowl Shape
Seat Height and Accessibility
Comfort height models sit about 17 to 19 inches from the floor, reducing knee strain for many users.
Consumer Reports noted that taller bowls benefit older adults and people with mobility issues while still fitting standard rough in dimensions.
Bowl Shape and Space Use
Round bowls fit smaller bathrooms, while elongated bowls provide more seating room and often score higher on comfort.
The testing process checks stability, surface ease to clean, and whether the bowl shape affects flushing effectiveness.
How Toilet Performance Is Tested
Flushing Effectiveness
Real world tests measure complete waste removal, potential streaking, and repeat flush requirements under standardized conditions.
High performing models use optimized trapways and bowl designs to move waste efficiently without excessive noise.
Water Efficiency and Cost
Units are rated on gallons per flush, with many meeting or exceeding the 1.28 gallon federal standard.
Choosing efficient toilets lowers long term water bills without sacrificing performance, a balance highlighted in the 2018 evaluations.
Noise, Construction Quality, and Installation Fit
Operational Sound and Vibration
Flush noise is measured to help buyers avoid disruptive bathrooms in quiet homes or apartments.
Consumer Reports observed that pressure assisted models tend to be louder, while gravity units offer quieter operation.
Build Materials and Long Term Durability
Vitreous china remains the standard, with attention to glazing smoothness and resistance to chipping.
Consistent manufacturing quality across 2018 models means fewer leaks, fewer repairs, and better resale value.
Buying Recommendations and Features
- Check the rough in measurement to ensure the new toilet aligns with existing plumbing.
- Compare water usage and local rebate programs to maximize savings.
- Test comfort height in person if possible, especially for users with joint concerns.
- Review flush performance scores for waste removal consistency and minimal clogging risk.
- Factor in long term maintenance costs, including replacement parts and cleaning accessibility.
Choosing the Right Toilet for Your Home
Use performance scores, water efficiency, and comfort features together to narrow options rather than relying on brand alone.
Measure your space, verify plumbing compatibility, and refer to updated Consumer Reports data to select a durable, reliable unit.
FAQ
Reader questions
Which Consumer Reports toilets 2018 models had the best flush performance?
Top scoring models like the Toto Drake II demonstrated powerful, reliable removal with lower rates of clogging and repeat flushing.
Are comfort height toilets worth the extra cost compared to standard models?
For users with mobility challenges or in households with older adults, the added comfort and safety often justify the higher initial price.
Do elongated bowls really make a difference in comfort?
Yes, elongated bowls typically offer more seating area, which many users find more comfortable, though they require slightly more space.
How much water can efficient toilets save compared to older designs?
Switching from pre 1990s toilets to 1.28 gpf models approved in 2018 can cut per flush water use by roughly 20 to 40 percent for average households.