The LG G5 from CNET represents a bold step in modular smartphone design, blending premium materials with swappable components. Reviewers praised its creative concept while noting some practical tradeoffs in everyday usability and ecosystem support.
Below is a concise overview of the device based on CNET and other authoritative sources, structured to highlight what truly matters to users evaluating this experiment in modularity.
| Category | Details | CNET Rating | User Sentiment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Display | 5.3-inch QHD IPS LCD, 2560 x 1440 | Positive | Sharp, bright outdoor visibility |
| Performance | Snapdragon 820, 4GB RAM | Very Good | Smooth but aging by later standards |
| Camera | 16MP rear, 8MP front | Good | Reliable daylight shots, soft low light |
| Battery | 2800 mAh with modular Battery Boost | Mixed | Flexible but limited standalone endurance |
| Build & Modularity | Metal chassis, hot-swappable modules | Neutral | Innovative yet fragile contacts |
Design and Build Quality
CNET highlighted the LG G5’s premium metallic build and refined finish, which feel significantly more substantial than plastic rivals. The side-mounted pogo pin connectors allow modules to attach with a satisfying click, and the removal process remains straightforward without special tools.
The addition of a Hi-Fi Quad DAC by Bang & Olufsen impressed both reviewers and audiophiles, delivering clearer separation and richer detail than many integrated smartphone solutions. However, the exposed contacts and moving tolerances raised concerns about dust ingress and potential damage over time.
Performance and Usability
Under the hood, the Snapdragon 820 and 4GB of RAM deliver responsive performance for everyday tasks and moderate gaming. CNET noted that the G5 handles multitasking well, though heavy benchmarks reveal its age compared to newer flagships.
Software support evolved through multiple Android versions with timely security patches, yet the niche module ecosystem limited long-term accessory availability. Users who embraced the modular concept enjoyed expanded functionality, while others found the extra components unnecessary.
Camera Experience
The 16MP rear camera produces naturally saturated images with pleasing contrast, and the optical image stabilization helps reduce handshake in varied lighting. CNET praised the solid default mode while noting that manual controls and third-party apps unlock more creative potential.
Video recording stabilizes well and captures clear audio, but low-light performance shows softness and noise compared with contemporary competitors. The camera app remains approachable for casual users while offering enough depth for enthusiasts.
Modularity and Ecosystem
CNET examined the range of modules, from the Battery Boost to the Cursor and VR Ready attachments, highlighting how they extend the phone’s capabilities beyond a standard slab. This flexibility is the core innovation, allowing niche accessories to transform the device for specific workflows or hobbies.
Despite the promise, the selection never reached mass-market scale, and compatibility gaps can confuse new users. The requirement to keep the back cover attached in many scenarios limits the modular experience, tempering what initially seems like limitless expansion.
Key Takeaways and Recommendations
- Prioritize the Hi-Fi Quad DAC if audio quality matters more than raw specs.
- Test module compatibility before committing, as support varies by region and firmware.
- Use the Battery Boost for occasional extra runtime, but plan for regular plug-in charging.
- Consider the G5 as a niche secondary device rather than a primary workhorse.
- Keep the original back cover and pogo pins clean to maintain reliable connections.
FAQ
Reader questions
Is the LG G5 still worth buying as a daily driver today?
It can serve as a capable secondary or highly specific primary device if you value modular experimentation, but performance and battery limitations make it less suitable as a mainstream daily compared to newer flagships.
How does the audio quality compare to non-modular flagships?
The integrated Hi-Fi Quad DAC and Bang & Olufsen tuning deliver richer, more detailed sound than many slab phones, especially with headphones, though volume levels and bass extension remain modest.
Are the modules reliable and easy to install?
Modules attach securely and work as advertised when seated correctly, but connector durability and dust resistance vary, and misalignment can cause intermittent issues that frustrate less technical users.
Does the G5 support fast charging with the battery module?
Battery Boost modules add capacity but do not significantly improve fast charging speeds, and some users report that swapping modules interrupts ongoing charge cycles, requiring re-plugging to resume rapid top-ups.